Bob Spangler
Welcome, and thanks for joining us. I'm Bob Spangler, Head of Municipal Finance. Today, we're talking about energy-as-a-service in healthcare, and why this partnership model is becoming more relevant as health systems look for new ways to address infrastructure needs, unlock savings, and preserve capital for core strategic priorities. I'm joined by two experts from our Energy and Infrastructure Solutions team, Blake Pinnell, a director, and Samadhi Asnes, a vice president, who have been closely involved in these conversations and in helping clients think through how these structures work in practice. Blake, Samadhi, thank you for joining us.
Blake Pinell
Great to be here.
Samadhi Asnes
Thanks for having us.
Bob Spangler
Let's start with the big picture. So, tell us what's going on in public healthcare today, in the sector right now, and what are the top challenges your clients are facing.
Blake Pinell
I'd say not-for-profit health systems nationally are collectively navigating a series of economic headwinds. As background, most not-for-profit health systems have, for really decades, structured their businesses to produce very modest operating margins, somewhere between 1% to 3% and this is due to the ethos of the space – management looks to reinvest every available dollar back into their communities, and this is obviously a very commendable mission, though any organization operating with this margin profile is more susceptible to macroeconomic factors. And right now, staffing shortages have lifted labor costs close to 50% of OpEx, reimbursement pressures are intensifying, and Medicaid funding cuts are expected to create an additional 2% to 4% EBITDA headwind over the next few years, and with decreased margins, you necessarily also see decreased CapEx budgets. These are some of the challenges that management is navigating, and we continue to be impressed by how well these organizations are responding to these dynamics. They're augmenting their business models while maintaining their commitments to their communities, and for our purposes today, they're evaluating and executing on innovative partnerships and financing approaches that can be accretive to the bottom line, and one of these really novel models is energy-as-a-service.
Bob Spangler
That's obviously an incredibly challenging environment, and so why has energy and infrastructure become such a focal point then for these health systems?
Blake Pinell
One thing our clients are acutely aware of is that hospitals consume two to three times more energy per square foot than a comparably sized commercial building, and this is in large part due to the 24-hour nature of the business, so any measure you can take, which can reduce utility consumption, tends to be a very high value proposition. And this is especially true for systems in specific geographies. In Northern California, for instance, electricity prices have seen 12% to 13% year-over-year growth for the last few years. So again, if you can trim 20-plus percent of your utility costs through executing a series of energy conservation measures, that can go a very long way in reducing enterprise OpEx and in many cases the savings are meaningful enough to create an opportunity to pay, not just for the measures themselves, but also additional deferred maintenance, while still solving for long-term break-even EBITDA. And I'd say one more thing: the most meaningful catalyst for increased interest outside of just the general operating pressures is the ability for these deals to be financed on a tax-exempt basis, and you know this radically reduces the aggregate cost of these programs for the health systems. These deals were, you know, previously all funded on a taxable basis, and back in the summer of 2024 RBC was part of the team that executed the first tax-exempt energy conservation measure-driven financing for one of these partnerships.
Bob Spangler
Okay, let's talk about the solution. What exactly is an EaaS partnership, and what specific problems is it designed to solve for healthcare organizations considering major upgrades?
Samadhi Asnes
So the goal of energy-as-a-service is to bring in an engineering firm to implement enterprise-wide energy infrastructure improvements, which in turn reduce energy consumption and lead to cost savings. This model allows health systems to fund these improvements through upfront capital -- often financed off balance sheet – where the projects might otherwise take years to fund and execute through the traditional capital allocation process. The engineering firm works with the health system to design and implement the infrastructure, while the health system retains book and title ownership of the upgrades and makes monthly payments. The result is that the health system can accelerate critical infrastructure upgrades without competing directly with other strategic capital priorities or losing control of essential PP&E.
Bob Spangler
So, let's talk about mechanics. How do the cash flows actually move between the health system, the operating partner, and the financing parties?
Samadhi Asnes
Yeah, so for the fund flows, the engineering company goes out and raises the capital for the upfront infrastructure investment through a non-consolidated special purpose entity and then guarantees the savings from the energy conservation measures with a cash make-whole payment if the targets aren't met. So, the health system enters into an agreement with an engineering company to make monthly payments sufficient to service the debt, and then any excess savings from the energy conservation measures either flow to the bottom line or fund additional borrowing, which could be used for additional deferred maintenance or unrestricted cash to use at management's discretion. I think one of the most common perceptions is around cost of capital so, as Blake said previously, these deals were done in the taxable market at a much higher rate, and the economics were much harder to justify. One of the major changes to these deals is being able to capitalize them in the tax-exempt municipal market at a cost of capital very similar to the health system's parent level debt.
Bob Spangler
Excellent. So what does this structure allow health systems to do, both financially and operationally, that traditional funding approaches simply cannot?
Blake Pinell
I'd say that the ideal transaction here is one which fully funds in one effort a selection of projects which produce the savings that, as Samadhi mentioned, improves asset resiliency and redundancy with the objective of producing savings that fully offset the cost of the program. Under a traditional funding approach, if a hospital wants to modernize its infrastructure, they bring their projects through an enterprise-level capital planning process, and candidly, these approval processes are simply not designed to facilitate energy efficiency investments. When competing for limited CapEx against clinical priorities, new equipment, emergency room expansion, it's very typical to earn approval on only a fraction of the necessary energy-related spend. So, just firstly, energy-as-a-service at its core just can efficiently finance a critical mass of these projects, and importantly, fund them on a cost-effective tax-exempt basis. And then, on the financial side, having these outlined utility expenses actually guaranteed by a well-capitalized partner, it's very meaningful as it provides a degree of confidence in the forecasted return profile. And then I'd say the benefits on the operational side are often where health systems see a fair bit of value relative to traditional financing approaches, and most of these partnerships are structured to transfer operational risk from the system to a professional operator.
Bob Spangler
So what are the real risks or downsides organizations should understand?
Samadhi Asnes
These are long-term partnerships. It's very critical to have a high degree of comfort with the engineering firm, and to know that they will still be there in 15 years. Also, these deals can be expensive to unwind, so it's also important to make sure that the partnership documents are written in a way that allows you to exit the partnership in a cost-effective way. Additionally, auditor guidelines and rating agency methodology could change in the future, so all EaaS transactions to date are treated as off balance sheet by the auditors, so that's not included in total debt; and the rating agencies have stated that they'll follow the accounting treatment, although they do look at these holistically as on credit. So you should be judicious about what projects are included in these partnerships.
Bob Spangler
Got it. Okay. Interesting. These are clearly multidisciplinary transactions, meaning a lot of different parties involved. How has RBC advised clients through this process? How does our municipal finance and infrastructure teams work across the bank to help get these deals over the finish line?
Blake Pinell
Yeah, these are indeed very complex partnerships. And thinking back on each of our completed engagements, there were at least four distinct teams from RBC that were involved. First, the Energy and Infrastructure Solutions team. This team effectively quarterbacks the transaction as the client's advocate, drawing on past experience to help the client evaluate commercial terms, assemble the right external team, organize and manage the full spectrum of work streams, (e.g., the technical review, financial modeling, financing, accounting, legal, tax, what have you), to ensure the milestones are met, and of course, that the partnership at the end of the day meets the stated objectives. Secondly, the not-for-profit healthcare coverage team. This team is involved because they understand the credit profile, the competitive dynamics, and governance constraints of these organizations, and, perhaps most importantly, how a long-term service agreement is going to interact with their existing capital structure. Our quantitative solutions team is going to manage the more complex financial modeling and scenario analysis, energy modeling. Our sales and trading colleagues provide guidance on investor requirements and financing execution as necessary, so we're very fortunate that RBC has the breadth of expertise to appropriately support our clients on these advisory engagements.
Bob Spangler
So can we walk through a recent deal we've done?
Samadhi Asnes
To date, 10 EaaS deals have been completed in the exempt markets, and so Novant Health Partnership is the largest EaaS transaction capitalized on a public tax-exempt basis. Through the transaction, Novant received $850 million in an upfront cash consideration, which was raised through an off-balance-sheet special purpose entity, and they also received a $558 million savings guarantee over the 30-year partnership term. So this transaction really proves that there's a broad market appetite for sizable transactions at a cost of capital, very consistent with the parent level debt. And it was great to work with the team and bring this from an idea to close in a six-month period.
Bob Spangler
That's terrific. Alright. So, then let's talk about the future. What is on the horizon for the future of EaaS? What do you see the next phase of growth, and how should our clients be prepared for it?
Blake Pinell
Over the past two years we've seen a truly remarkable acceleration in the degree of interest in these deals, and the number of closed deals. It's developed into a model that I would say nearly 50% or more of the health systems we talked to are actively exploring. There's certainly more developers and counterparties that have taken notice of this activity and are entering the space. It's a healthy development for the health systems, you know, there's more competition, more innovation, most likely even more competitive pricing and ultimately more flexibility to find an arrangement that fits an organization's unique needs. The tax-exempt model is also beginning to move beyond healthcare. We've seen increased interest from universities, school districts, other public institutions, each of which share many of the same characteristics as health systems. In terms of preparation, it all starts internally, of course, just making sure that the right stakeholders are engaged: finance, facilities, treasury, executive leadership. And then from there, a good next step is just to organize billing and usage data across the various utilities that you use, any master planning documentation, understanding your consumption baseline, and knowing where your largest cost centers are, and it's pretty likely that developers have already reached out to health systems that are thinking about this sort of deals, so I would suggest just being open to taking their calls. There's valuable market intel that can be gathered, even if you're still years away from transacting. And, as always, RBC is happy to take a call at any stage of the process. That is what we're here for.
Bob Spangler
My guess is we will see many more EaaS deals coming. Blake and Samadhi, thank you both so much for breaking down the mechanics of energy-as-a-service. So, if your team is starting to explore energy-as-a-service, if you just want to bounce some ideas around to see how these structures could work for your specific facilities, we'd love to hear from you and continue the conversation. So, please reach out to Blake and Samadhi, or your RBC coverage team, or myself. Thanks for tuning in.
[DISCLAIMER]
This content is based on information available at the time it was recorded and is for informational purposes only. It is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation, and no recommendations are implied. It is outside the scope of this communication to consider whether it is suitable for you and your financial objectives.
*Transcript has been edited for clarity.