How are fintech incumbents resisting AI disruption? | Transcript


Jason Gurandiano  00:06

Welcome back to Strategic Alternatives, the RBC Capital Markets podcast. I'm Jason Gurandiano, Head of U.S. Technology Banking, as well as Global Head of Fintech Banking here at RBC Capital Markets. Today we're going to take a deep dive into the exciting realm of fintech. Fintech continues to be an area of newsworthy debate, and we are just off the back of our 11th annual Fintech conference, which brought together companies, investors, and industry leaders from across the Fintech ecosystem, and we'll use that as a lens into a broader exploration and conversation about the trends that are impacting and shaping the broader Fintech sector. We had over 50 featured companies, we had over 430 plus attendees, and over 740 plus investor interactions. This was by far the largest amount of engagement we've seen by investors and corporates in the last five years, and there was strong engagement both from the public and private investors looking to deploy incremental capital into the sector. It's also worth noting that the private markets are just as robust as the public markets as it relates to scope, scale, and quantum, with private financing exceeding $110 billion over the last 18 months alone, which indicates the ongoing bullish view of both public and private investors as it relates to the prospects for fintech, even with the backdrop of uncertainty of SaaS apocalypse and/or AI. I'm joined on this podcast by Matt Thomas, Managing Director in our Technology Investment Banking team focused on fintech across all of the sub verticals, as well as Asif Ahsan, Managing Director in our M&A team, focusing on the technology sector with a major in fintech overall. As I mentioned, we do think the fintech conference that we just hosted provides a unique jumping-off point into a wide variety of topics for discussion, given the mix of both public and private investors that we had at the conference. With that, Matt, I will turn it over to you to run through some of the messages that resonated with you during the conference.

Matthew Thomas  02:15

I think you really hit the nail on the head. There was awesome energy at the conference. I think companies were keen to be chatting with investors, to really be on their front foot, and that was a big shift, I would say, from what we saw kind of in the first quarter of the year, where really all of the conversation in the broader sector was defensive about who's going to be disruptive. I would say one of the big themes that that we saw coming out of the conference was the CEOs there were talking about how they're winning. They were emphasizing how innovation is accelerating, how they're seeing kind of strengthened adoption and new solutions and so I would say broadly felt a lot of bullishness coming out from the speakers that we had on stage. From an investor perspective, a lot of the private equity firms and growth equity funds who we had attending, they're really looking for that next new investment. So it was definitely an environment where people were on the hunt from a private investor side of things. From the public side I would say it felt like a lot of the energy was around understanding how both AI and some of the other trends you were hitting on are going to impact their current investments, right? So felt a little bit more about understanding who are who are going to be the winners in their existing ecosystem on that front, and a little less focus on, what is the next IPO in the category, right? It feels like on the topic of AI now it's about proof not promises on that front, and so definitely had a few CEOs on stage talking about AI washing doesn't work anymore and it's really about pointing to real operational impacts, both on revenue and on the cost side, and how it's transforming their ability to win. I think there was a really interesting theme about the ability to actually monetize some of the data that's always been sitting on these platform and network businesses in fintech, and there's always been a promise, but not necessarily one that was driving real revenues. I think that's rapidly changing, particularly for some of the companies we had on stage who have really attractive footprints as kind of system of record and workflow solutions.

Jason Gurandiano  04:32

So, Matt, one question I have for you is: you talk about you know some of the qualitative aspects that define a best-in-class fintech company. You did mention a couple of KPIs. Like, what does good look like as relates to fintech companies? You know, both from a top line growth perspective, a margin perspective, a retention perspective, how do you sort of think about that?

Matthew Thomas  04:51

I would say first and foremost, retention’s always a really important question. I'd say even more so in this environment where there's questions about does AI create real disruption on what have been super sticky incumbent businesses, right? And so probably the first question is, what's your gross retention? And in this environment, you want to be in the mid-90s or higher if you really want to capture interest. I'd say the second thing people are looking to see is the ability to drive growth within the base, and I'll add on a caveat that now they want to see some of that growth defined as AI-driven revenues and so we're seeing a lot of companies, go to pains both in the public and private markets to kind of emphasize their bookings momentum for new AI products or AI powered products that they've launched into the market. I think people certainly want to see durability in those upsell motions. I think a little bit easier to introduce new features. What could have taken 12 to 18 months is now happening in you know a month or two, and that acceleration of innovation is creating a faster upsell cycle. I think for many of the companies we deal with. So I'd say those are a couple of the key things. I'd say growth always matters - there's a lot more interest if you're growing at 20% than if you're growing in the single digits.

Jason Gurandiano  06:10

And maybe, Asif, this is a good time to sort of loop in the conversation here. Obviously one of the challenges that we're seeing out there has been, aside from volatility of multiples, is how do you underwrite growth or how do you underwrite a reacceleration of growth, and how do you sort of quantify or define either the headwind or tailwind from AI in valuation discussions? So, do you have a perspective around that?

Asif Ahsan  06:33

It's interesting because even with all the volatility and change in the market, growth remains the single most important factor when investors are valuing a company or when a strategic is considering making an acquisition. Ultimately, if a company isn't winning new customers or growing with their existing customers, something is broken either from a market, product, or sales perspective, and frankly, that isn't great. What's more interesting is that we're seeing is very binary. Winners are getting really robust multiples, and perceived losers are trading near cyclical lows or just not trading. If we don't think this company is going to be around or much bigger in two to three years, people frankly aren't interested. In terms of underwriting growth, it's very much as a show-me market. Buyers are looking to see consistent historical growth before believing projections. On the private side, when we're selling companies, we're spending a lot of time around bookings to revenue, forward pipeline, win rates, and the amount of opportunities for a market to really support the near-term projections. Frankly, some of the metrics that Matt talked about around retention and margins are also pretty important. In terms of AI, it very much depends on the industry and company, and how they're positioned vis-a-vis their key moats. For some sectors like information services with proprietary data or market structure, it's been a tailwind. For other parts of financial software, frankly, it's been a headwind.

Jason Gurandiano  07:37

Matt, how do you think about the resiliency of the fintech software model versus the broader software model, because I think what we've seen is a little bit of a bifurcation. If you look at you know something as simple as credit spreads, for example, financial software is kind of back to par, you know pre or pre-SaaS apocalypse levels, whereas the broader software credit sector remains heavily impacted. You know what is it that is unique to Fin software in particular that you think has allowed it to recover more quickly, and where we're starting to see you know accelerating pace of transactions increase across each of those underlying sub verticals?

Matthew Thomas  08:14

First of all, I would say, in general, vertical expertise has taken on an outsized importance in the broader market. If you looked at the data where software as a category is pulled back the most is in some of the more horizontal areas that are out there. It’s almost definitionally, when you talk about software sold into financial institutions, it tends to be very specialized. Those specializations are for some good reasons. I think as an industry, financial services is one of the most regulated out there. And that regulation entails a lot of requirements around data, and data protections as well as controls that are meant to ensure the health of the underlying financial institutions. And so because of that, what you see as you look across each of the different categories is really subvertical specialists who have built really strong businesses, in part, by being highly embedded in their underlying end customers' operations, right? And so, if I take the insurance software ecosystem, for example, some of the companies who we had presenting at the conference, their platforms really underpin the entire life cycle of what the insurance carrier does for their business. We look across the space, gross retentions for a lot of the system of record businesses in financial software tend to be in the very high 90s and typical contracts with the customers can be anywhere from five to 10 years. When you contrast that with the typical public SaaS company, that's going to be you know one two years on average. What that does from our perspective, I think it certainly erects some very significant barriers to disruption, and candidly, barriers to startups driving real traction. When you're deeply embedded, you're also very well positioned to go on offense, and that's what we're seeing a lot of the companies in this space doing. They've been aggressively rolling out both their AI solutions, but then also new products that that really leverage the fact that oftentimes they're sitting on 20 to 30 years of underlying proprietary data for their customers that they have the right to be able to productize, and monetize in certain ways, and that actually is creates some exciting upside, not just downside protection.

Asif Ahsan  10:37

What we're seeing this year across most of technology and software, in the context of M&A situations, is perspective requires having third-party consultants and advisors, and seeing how replicable their software stack really is. It's interesting because we've actually seen transactions which have either been re-traded or just shut down completely because competitive moats that they talked about really weren’t there. The vertical enterprise and regulatory nature of fintech makes this much more difficult. For example, a large enterprise like RBC really isn't going to vibe code its own software, and there's value in working with an established vendor. So that's another area where fintech is broadly more insulated in the context of some of the AI disruption that we've been seeing.

Matthew Thomas  11:14

And look, it shows out in the data on average, broader horizontal software is still down give or take 30% depending on which subcategory you look at versus where it ended last year, financial software as a bucket, as we track it, is down about 10%. So not to say SaaSpocalypse didn't have impacts on you know where companies are trading but generally it has been a lot more resilient.

 

Jason Gurandiano  11:36

When you look at the broader financial software landscape, which of the sub verticals excites you the most, both from an opportunity set slash growth set perspective, and secondarily from a transaction perspective? Is it cap market software? Is it wealth management software? Is it insuretech?

Matthew Thomas  11:54

Wealthtech and insurtech in particular seems to have attracted the most interest. I think you know part of that has to do with the fact that you've certainly got some at-scale vendors in that space who really seem to tick all the right boxes as both the system of record that underpins the underlying business. We're certainly seeing deal activity there as well, right? And so I think we're bullish on M&A in both of those sectors over the next 12 to 18 months, and I've certainly seen some good activity over the last 12 months on that front as well. If I think about capital markets technology, I would say that's an area where there's strong interest, but I'd also say the underlying customers who have their own AI budgets are at certain points, looking at it and saying can I do this better? The Incumbents are maybe a little less advantaged there on that front, and so that that's where we do see some of the smaller vendors in the ecosystem getting really good traction with some of their offerings.

Joe Coletti   13:04

We've covered a lot of ground in the episode today, from the current state of fintech investing and what investors are looking for, to valuation trends, M&A activity, and the resilience of financial software across the broader ecosystem. In our next episode, part two, we'll continue the conversation and turn our attention to some of the technologies and infrastructure trends reshaping fintech, including the evolution of payments, agentic commerce, stablecoins, and digital assets.

Joe Coletti

You've been listening to Strategic Alternatives, the RBC Capital Markets podcast. This episode was recorded on August 12, 2026. Subscribe to Strategic Alternatives on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. See you all next time.