Speaker 1:
Hello, and welcome to Macro Minutes. During each episode, we'll be joined by RBC Capital Markets experts to provide high conviction insights on the latest developments in financial markets and the global economy. Please listen to the end of this recording for important disclosures.
Peter Schaffrik:
Welcome to the latest episode of Macro Minutes, the European Edition. My name's Peter Schaffrik, and I shall be your host for today. We're recording on the afternoon of Thursday, September the 17th in the wake of the Bank of England's policy announcement earlier today. Today, we'll be zooming in on the latest central bank meetings from the ECB and Bank of England respectively. And given that we're recording straight after the BoE, I suggest let's start there. Today, I'm joined by Cathal Kennedy, who's RBC's UK economist, no better person to speak about the Bank of England with. Cathal, so no press conference today, but you've had time to digest the bank's announcements. What are your main takeaways from the decision today?
Cathal Kennedy:
Hello, Peter, and hello everybody who's listening in. Look, I think the easy bit from today, the policy decision, hold rates, 3.75%, the vote split on the MPC, 6-3, both as expected in advance, so no surprises there. But I think where the key changes were was in the language the MPC deployed, if you will. I think there was more of an acknowledgement, particularly in the policy summary of the upside risks to inflation, and indeed the new estimate of where inflation would peak early in the new year. But I think the one major area we saw a shift was in the individual members.
Now, we've spoken before about there being three groups in the MPC, three dovish members, three hawkish members, and three floating voters in between. And those floating voters are roughly Governor Bailey, Clare Lombardelli, and Dave Ramsden. And you could see it all their three paragraphs, much more of a hawkish shift from where we were back in July. And that's just reflected what we've seen in energy prices since, the governor admitting that rate hikes might be needed if the situation persists. Previously, if you remember back in the July press conference, he was adamant that the journalists shouldn't leave the room thinking that the bank was edging towards rate hikes. So it's quite a big difference from where we were just six weeks ago.
Clare Lombardelli said at July press conference that her decision to vote for a whole then wasn't a close judgment. Well, today she's again warning of the risk, if you will, that policy might have to be tightened in the face of what we're seeing in energy markets.
And Dave Ramsden, just a week ago at the Treasury Select Committee describing the domestic inflationary backdrop in the UK as benign. And today speaking about, again, the necessity perhaps to raise rates if the situation persists. So you can just see that shift in the language, real shift in the language from where we were back in July.
Peter Schaffrik:
Okay, so I get that, Cathal. So what about the outlook from here? I know that you've been of the view that the MPC would try to hold rates given where the starting point is higher, given where the economy is a bit weaker. And I think the phrase you've used in the past is that they would be reluctant hikers. Has what you've seen today or you read today rather changed any of your thinking?
Cathal Kennedy:
For what it's worth, I still think there'll be reluctant hikers. I think their hand is almost being forced here by external events. We've always said that as important as the level of energy prices is how long they remain elevated for. In essence, the longer they remain higher, the harder it is to ignore or certainly to judge that the second round effects, those all important wage effects that the central banks are looking for, that they won't be as pronounced as to where should we say in the post 2022 world.
But in the here and now, not only are prices elevated, but a possibility of a resolution looks remote. So it's difficult for the bank, even if domestic inflationary fixture is benign to completely look through what we're seeing. And I think today there was mention in the minutes about inflation going above 4% or around 4% early in the new year. I think the bank has found itself where the ECB was last week, was the world in which your most recent inflation forecasts have suddenly been overtaken by events beyond your control in essence, if you will.
Peter Schaffrik:
Yeah, I definitely think that's a good way to phrase the ECB. I mean, my take from last week's ECB meeting was, I mean obviously the hike was expected, but clearly when you look at what Lagarde was saying, she was asked or she was given multiple opportunities to push back on further rate hikes. They've raised now to 250, which they previously said is the top end of neutral. She pushed that away. So she had multiple, multiple occasions to push back or at least put a line in the sand, but she didn't. So I think in my mind that's exactly the right thing, exactly the right phrasing, the external events have pushed the envelope, so to speak. So I mean, it's easier for the ECB to hike because the starting point was lower, but I think you're absolutely right. The similarities with the Bank of England is very stark and clearly the focus going forward is on the second round effects very clearly.
Cathal Kennedy:
Yeah. And look, for me, much as you can judge the second round effects might be more muted. And like I said, there are good arguments to think that might be the case, particularly in the UK to loosens the labor market, but you are getting to the point where you may have to do something. So you want to keep those options on the table, don't you?
Peter Schaffrik:
Yeah. Again, I think this is exactly where the ECB is. I mean, if I take a step back, I mean, the ECB has initially broad rates from the lower end of the neutral range to the top end now. And then they have said, "Well, look, what we want to see now is how does the current inflation that we have, which is like in the UK, essentially in the energy complex, how does that propagate through the economy?" So far, you just don't see it propagating through the economy. It's basically in the energy part. But what they've said is, well, particularly if it were to come to a point where wages start to rise, that would be an issue because that's exactly what happened in '22 as well, and that would be an issue. So far, we don't see that yet and they make that absolutely clear. In fact, they make that abundantly clear, which also to me suggests that they're probably not rushing into things.
But if that is the case, then they would go. And that's certainly also where they see the risk. And let me just be very, very clear. I think wages are a lagging indicator, and it's not a surprise that we don't see wage growth just yet. The labor market is a lagging indicator generally, but it remains tight, very tight actually. And if I take other ECB speakers, for instance, I mean, there was an interview, I think two weeks ago by [inaudible 00:07:59] Bank President Nagel with Le Monde in France where he said, "Let's see what the wage negotiation round in 2027 is going to bring." So in my mind, going forward, that is ultimately where the risks lie that A, we have, as you said earlier in your comments, that we have a longer period of time where energy prices remain elevated. And then secondly, that they feed into other parts of the basket, particularly into the labor market developments.
Cathal Kennedy:
Yeah, I think you said that's the key. At the moment, the central banks are still trying to make a judgment call, if you will, on what those wage impacts may be, like a stress, it is a judgment call here. But look, let me ask you a question from an economist or a strategist, if you will. We're both saying here that the ECB and the bank won't rush things, they'll be careful in the hiking cycle, even if it'll try and stay ahead of the curve, if you will. But then why is the market pricing in such an aggressive path? And I suppose in that context, where do you see the opportunities for investors here?
Peter Schaffrik:
Yeah, I mean, look, is the market pricing an aggressive path? It certainly is. We're pricing in both cases for the bank and for the ECB more than one hike before the end of the year with just two meetings, which suggest there is a non-zero probability implied that they would do either 50 basis point hike or more than one hike, which I think we can both agree looks fairly remote.
Also, I think if you look at where the so-called terminal rate is, I mean, it came down over the last two days a little, but at one point we were pricing 350 for the ECB and around about 5% for the Bank of England.
Now, when I compare the underlying economic situation, I mean, almost certainly inflation is probably going to be around 4% and change around the turn of the year with the given information set and the given level of energy prices that we currently have, which is high, but it's not anywhere close to the double-digit numbers that we had after '22, '23. And back then we had just 50 or 25 basis points higher rates, so 4% for the ECB and 525 for the Bank of England. So in my mind, we have priced in a path that looks speedy and looks also very high at its end point.
However, having said all that, I do think that this is probably also owed to a bit of positioning in the market. You know how it is, it's not only or it's not always necessarily the best guess of what markets really think, it's quite often also which way the market was positioned up priori. And then when we had over the last weekend, the attacks on the Saudi pipeline and energy prices were rising quite sharply, I think quite a lot of those positions that were already opposing these implied path needed to be taken off and just pushed markets in one direction.
So frankly, I think the opportunity in my mind lies probably in the shortest expiries where you have a relatively good handle on what the central banks ultimately will do, whereas further out, let's say the end point that can move around a lot with energy prices and energy prices these days are extremely volatile. So I would probably stick with the closer maturities if I wanted to oppose the market, if that makes any sense.
But actually, Cathal, let me turn this around a bit. You just asked me a question from an economist to a strategist. Let me ask a question from a strategist to an economist. So will they, the Bank of England, will they go this side of Christmas? That's number one. And number two, how much can we reasonably expect for them to deliver in this current environment?
Cathal Kennedy:
So your first question, will they go this side of Christmas? I'd probably say yes. I would've thought that of the two remaining meetings, November looks the most likely just because you have all the information you need to justify a rate hike at that stage, new forecast, et cetera, at a press conference to give a future direction if you want to.
On the second one, how much will they deliver? I honestly think from here, anything that the bank delivers would be on the modest side, let's say. I'm still kind of clinging to the words of Huw Pill from about a week or two ago when he said that raising bank rates now need not be the start of a prolonged and aggressive series of hikes. And I think that speaks to what the MPC will be trying to do, which is rather than reigning in inflation in the here and now, it's really about managing expectations and stopping those second run effects before they get started, if you will, before the wage demands become too high.
Peter Schaffrik:
That makes a lot of sense to me. Without putting words into your mouth, if I sort of summarize, I guess, what you've been telling us and also where my head is at, I think the direction of travel is very clear. Inflation is at risk of rising further and the energy price risks are for real and the central banks will react. The question is rather will they react by the same token or by the same amount that the market is currently implying? And there probably for an investor, we would argue maybe not as quickly and maybe not as far as what the market is currently implying.
That brings us to the end of our discussion. Thank you very much, Cathal, for joining me today. I will now let you get back to putting pen to paper and write up the Bank of England meeting for our investors. And thank you everyone who listened in and thank you for joining us and I hope you'll join us again at the next edition of Macro Minutes.
This content is based on information available at the time it was recorded and is for informational purposes only. It is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation and no recommendations are implied. It is outside the scope of this communication to consider whether it is suitable for you and your financial objectives.