[00:00:06] Ron Ruffini: Hello and welcome to our Partner of Choice podcast, where we bring together perspectives from across RBC Capital Markets to explore the market forces shaping our clients' decisions and how we combine insight, execution, and solutions to help them respond. I'm Ron Ruffini, Head of Commodities Risk Solutions for both EMEA and Asia-Pac. Today, we're looking at a period of significant change for the global commodity markets. From energy security to intensifying competition for base metals, global macro forces are putting pressure on supply, prices, and client decisions. But beneath the daily price volatility lies a critical question: how much reflects intensified cyclical pressures, and how much points to a more lasting structural shift? To explore what this means for managing exposure, financing activities, and planning ahead, and how RBC is strengthening its commodities capabilities, Across the globe. I'm joined by Ian Penny, Global Head of Metals at RBC Capital Markets. Ian, welcome to the pod.
[00:01:00] Ian Penney: Hi, Ron. Happy to be here.
[00:01:02] Ron Ruffini: Ian, we're seeing a distinct and evolving supply and demand dynamics across the global commodities landscape. Where are you seeing the most consequential shifts? Which dynamics appear cyclical? Which point to more lasting structural change? And where are those distinctions becoming harder to make?
[00:01:18] Ian Penney: I think the most consequential shift has to be in energy, right? You've got geopolitical shifting landscapes all over the planet, and that's being borne out in near-term supply disruptions. I don't think either of us were expecting to see the year we've seen so far. I think on the metal side, there's more of a structural shift in demand. The electrification of the planet is leading to much stronger demand for certain metals, rare earths, that’s feeding back into geopolitical tensions. But I think the two markets are shifting somewhat in their timeframes. I think the fact that 22 out of 25 of the BCOM index have hit all-time highs in 2026 tells you everything you need to know about a commodity supercycle. But it's not quite as simple as that. I do think there is a genuine shift. I think some pressures are going to ease geopolitically. I mean, you’ve probably heard it more times than me, Ron, but nothing cures higher oil prices like higher oil prices, right? So I think we will see a shift in that, but the structural shift we're going to see on the metals front is probably more consequential in the medium term. And with that, I'd say clients have to plan accordingly. I don’t know you have any thoughts?
[00:02:28] Ron Ruffini: Yeah, I think, you know, commodity hedging is obviously not a new thing, right? I mean, you and I have been in this market for way too long, right? And we've obviously had clients over the last few decades, both from a producing perspective and a consuming perspective, and the intermediaries hedging quite actively in their exposures. And one of the big things that we learned in 2022, which this obviously happened after the invasion of Ukraine, was the spike in energy prices around the world, and specifically in Europe, right? Obviously prices were all over the place, but to put things into context, European gas prices where they're trading around, I don't know, €60 or €70 per megawatt hour now went all the way up to €300, right? And financing those positions became a huge thing, right? Whether it's trading on exchange, but actually moving the physical molecules of barrels around the world. So I think in 2022, a lot of the energy clients, whether they're buyers, sellers, or intermediaries, learned their lesson that they had to have a lot of liquidity from a financing perspective in place, whether it's trading or just in their physical operations. The reason why I'm making the reference to 2022 is we saw the same thing in the metals market earlier this year, right? So whether it's base metals or precious metals. And when gold prices, of course, are trading around $4,000 an ounce now, but they were, you know, $5,400 earlier this year. So it was very critical at the beginning of this year for a lot of our clients, particularly in the base metals and in the precious metals markets, to make sure that they had ample liquidity in the financing. The other thing is, yes, a lot of our clients have been hedging for many, many years, many decades, right? But hedging sometimes did not hedge exactly your exposure, right? A lot of consumers globally, historically, have hedged with the most liquid marker out there, which is oil, whether it's Brent or it's WTI or data Brent to hedge their exposure in fuel. But in reality, they're using diesel, they're using jet fuel, right? They're not using Brent. As we saw, again, back to the supply and demand equation of things in the commodities markets, there was a serious lack of supply in the fuel markets, right? So if you were consuming diesel, if you're consuming jet, yeah, these exposures became quite aggressively bigger and your existing hedges that you had in place, if you were using oil as a proxy, were really not cutting it, right? So a lot of things have changed. And of course we say that every year in commodities. But I think in particular, if we focus on financing and underlying hedge, that's a couple very big things that we saw throughout this year.
[00:05:02] Ian Penney: Yeah, I think you've hit the nail on the head. I think basis risk is something that was very much underestimated in the metals market and probably the same in energy as well, right? And then in terms of a geographical split, challenges to UK and Europe have to be energy security. I think that's more acutely felt here than anywhere else in the world.
[00:05:22] Ron Ruffini: Exactly. So Ian, in the UK and the European metals markets, obviously managing exposure can involve, as I just mentioned, both derivatives and financing, right? How do they fit together in your opinion? What makes financing the biggest difference for a client?
[00:05:35] Ian Penney: The CapEx involved in holding inventory is clear to all. And when we have these blowups that we've seen in the last few years, financing that inventory becomes very, very difficult. We saw with the tariff volatility across metals, the financing rates were double digit. And for any corporate, no matter how cash rich they are, those financing costs are gonna eat into margins. So I think having an ability to hedge that, and then tying that in with the price derivatives hedging is absolutely key. So on the financing side, it's about optimizing capital structure. It's about innovative solutions to find the best way to finance it, whether that's secured or whether it's more unsecured, but, you know, getting it right in the first place is gonna pay off dividends. And not ignoring it as well. I think the beauty of what we're doing at RBC with our build-out is combining the two. And I think that platform that, you know better than anyone, we've put in place on the financing side, building up that trust with the clients, using that RBC branding to get where we are, gives us such a good foot in the door with our derivatives build-out. We have trusted relationships with clients who come to us for advice, and now we have a stacked bench of expertise that can offer price risk hedging all the way through the curve, all the way through the lifecycle of that trade. So that strong financing platform plus the derivatives expertise is definitely something we can offer here at RBC. And those kinds of trades are going to mitigate that risk and finance that working capital in a much more efficient manner. Okay, Ron, my turn to ask you a question. RBC has made a significant investment in specialist commodities expertise across EMEA and APAC. What opportunity was that investment designed to address, and what can the expanded franchise now offer corporate clients that couldn't previously?
[00:07:27] Ron Ruffini: Yep, and I'm glad you asked this question because that's the reason why I joined RBC. So let's rewind about a year ago and look at what we had at RBC on a global basis in commodities. And if we look at the North America franchise, I think we had a very strong energy derivatives business and a very strong energy financing business. And if we looked at what we had in Europe, we had a very strong precious metals and base metals financing business, right? So in essence, what we wanted to do is plug in what we did really, really well in EMEA and Asia-Pac and do the same thing in North America. And if we fast forward now, if we look at North America, where do we add? We add expertise, subject matter expertise in North America on the metals financing business. So that was something that we were very good again in Europe, but not so much in North America. So we plugged that hole. We also added to a US power business, which is also something that we were lacking to a certain degree. And obviously a very, very important market, especially with everything that's happening I mean, it was always an important market, but even more so nowadays with data centers and the likes, right? And then in Europe, we plugged in our holes that we had here and hired precious metals derivative people and energy derivative people with also some financing background. And we did the same thing in Asia-Pac, right? So in all, obviously a very big, significant investment by RBC that fits very nicely into not only what the markets business, where you and I and, Ian sit, wanted to do, but also fits very nicely with what the bank wants to do on a global scale. So the question is, what do we have now that we didn't have a year or so ago? We have added both on sales and trading, on average, subject matter experts in commodities with somewhere in between 15 and 25 years of commodities experience. The group of folks that we've put together are definitely best in class. They have seen it all. They have done it all. And all I encourage to our clients and our listeners is talk to us, call us, contact us. We are now ready for anything that you guys need. Of course, we're doing this on a proactive basis as well, but just the level of expertise, I think what we built here at RBC is second to none. Ian, can you bring to life maybe an example of how our expanded capabilities have helped a client navigate this difficult commodities market?
[00:09:51] Ian Penney: I think a point I've always tried to hammer home is to be very interconnected within our client base. Some of our clients will be trading with each other, whether that's sending material in to be refined somewhere else, and we want to be part of that value chain throughout. So for a high-level example, we may pick some inventory up in North America, whether that is primary output or secondary output. We can finance that metal from North America into Europe, whether that's going into a refinery or a smelter. We can take that outturn, we could potentially distribute the outturn material into our client base. We can finance it until our client has found someone to distribute into, and hopefully we can add a derivatives layer to that to hedge some of that price exposure. Being at the center of that is absolutely critical to the franchise we are trying to build because we have more visibility on what's going on, which is definitely what our credit department likes, but it's also just efficiencies, right? Like we are absolutely the touchpoint between all of these clients, and that is something that I've always strived to get to.
[00:10:57] Ron Ruffini: And I think, Ian, that ties in really nicely with what I was saying about financing being important and obviously derivatives being important, right? So if you can offer the end-to-end solutions to them, so not just one or the other, obviously it adds a lot more value from many perspectives. More specifically, that you don't have to go out to two or three different counterparties to get done what you can do with one. I mean, it's a win-win situation.
[00:11:19] Ian Penney: Ron, we've worked in commodities for many years. We've seen the market evolve through different cycles. Looking back over the past decade or so, or maybe even two, how different is the environment corporate clients are operating in today? And as we look ahead to 2027, what do you think should businesses be preparing for?
[00:11:37] Ron Ruffini: If we look at the decade between 2010 and 2020, at least from my perspective, I think commodities was kind of meh, right?
[00:11:47] Ian Penney: Yeah.
[00:11:47] Ron Ruffini: And there was ample investment, ample supply, everything kind of, it was okay, right? And it wasn't until COVID that things changed drastically and COVID hits all markets. Globally in disarray. Commodities will of course never avoid a good crisis, as I always say, and everything went bonkers, right? But then the market and the world woke up from COVID and that's when you really saw the supply chain distress, right? And it was across all commodities. And I really can't remember a time when all commodities markets were in disarray, right? So it was not just energy or was not just metals or ags, it was everything. And then of course, right after that, we have the invasion of Ukraine. Obviously that takes out Russia, right? Which is a huge producer, not just of energy, but also of metals. Ukraine obviously is also a big producer, particularly in grains and metals as well. But at the end of the day, you have COVID, you have the waking up of the world after COVID, you have the Russian invasion, throws everything in disarray. Yet things have been drastically different than in the decade of 2010 to COVID, right? And if you look at people that are in the commodities markets, whether it's banks, hedge funds, trading houses, refiners, anybody, right? You can look at their revenues, provided again that you have ample liquidity and credit lines and things like that. Yeah, they've had their best years ever starting with 2022. And if you probably look at the second-best year, it's this year. And I think this, the supply chain situation with regards to everything that's happening around the world in every commodities market, it's here to stay for a while. And you can definitely see it from the volatility markets of participants reaping either the rewards or of course bearing the pain. And then I think the other thing is, and everybody has risk managers within their institutions, right? But I think risk managers nowadays really have to play a role of just looking at what's the worst-case scenario in everything. You really do need somebody in your institution that is not just looking at what normally happens, but actually, you know, challenging what could be the worst-case scenario, right? And again, given the folks that we've hired, you can call us and talk about these things, right? Again, they've seen it all, they've done it all, and we're here to help for that, right? But I think, yeah, commodities markets are going to be ripping. That's just the nature of the beast at the moment with everything that is happening in the physical markets. And folks just need to be open-minded to that and basically lean on their financial advisors or whomever it is, right? Risk managers, et cetera, to make sure that like basically no stone is left unturned with regards to what the overall exposure could be to your company.
[00:14:30] Ian Penney: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you should definitely work in sales, Ron. And I'm saying from the trader's perspective, I agree, like COVID changed everything, right? And I think there was inherent slightly lazy risk positions that the whole market had on the so-called experts, whether that was interest rate risk, whether that was basis risk, whether that was completely ignoring any kind of tariff risk, which obviously leads itself into basis risk. But I think we all learned a lot in 2020. COVID changed everything. I think the frequency of these black swan events is significantly shortened. And I think prudent risk management, working with experts, is definitely something that everybody needs to bear in mind.
[00:15:16] Ron Ruffini: And just for the record, I do work in sales. Ian, thank you very much. I appreciate that. You should definitely stick to trading.
[00:15:23] Ian Penney: Stick to trading
[00:15:24] Ron Ruffini: Yeah
[00:15:24] Ian Penney: I don't know if everyone would agree with that, but…
[00:15:26] Ron Ruffini: Look, at the end of the day, I'm super proud with what RBC had before our investment. I'm super happy with what we've bolted on. And I'm super excited about what we're going to do going forward, right? Because I think it is a great team. I think it fits a very nice culture within RBC, which will just permeate into our client relationships out there. So Ian, this was great. Thank you for all your insights. Please, please do reach out to folks on our desk with regards to any questions that you may have on commodities markets. As you can see, we love to geek out on this stuff, so we're not shy for words for sure. So thank you. Been a pleasure, Ian. Thank you for your time. And to our listeners, thank you for joining us. This episode was recorded on November 10th, 2026. We'll also be continuing the wider markets conversation at our RBC Micro and Markets Conference in London on December 2nd and 3rd. Please speak to your RBC If you'd like to explore how RBC Capital Markets can support your business, please contact your usual RBC representative. You can find more episodes and insights on the RBC Capital Markets website and listen and subscribe to The Partner of Choice wherever you listen to your podcasts.
[00:16:44] DISCLAIMER:
This content is based on information available at the time it was recorded, and is for informational purposes only. It is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation, and no recommendations are implied. It is outside the scope of this communication to consider whether it is suitable for you and your financial objectives.