Speaker 1
Welcome to Powering Sustainable Ideas, a podcast series from RBC Capital Markets, where we speak with the leaders and companies powering the sustainable future. In this episode, we’re bringing you insights from RBC’s Energy Transition Conference in London this past June, exploring some of the latest advances in the decarbonisation of transport. Joining the conversation are Jonathon Counsell, Group Head of Sustainability at IAG, one of Europe’s biggest airline groups and Ryan Mangold, Chief Financial Officer at FirstGroup, a major UK-based bus and rail company. Together with Rob Jurd, Head of Industrials Investment Banking in Europe at RBC Capital Markets, they discuss the challenges, opportunities, and emerging solutions that are shaping the path to lower emission transport. Now, let’s dive into the conversation.
Rob Jurd
Perhaps I could ask you to each just introduce yourselves in the context of what your involvement is at your organizations as it relates to decarbonisation. Jonathan, perhaps we start with you on that.
Jonathon Counsell
Yeah, so Group Sustainability Director, IAG. Yes, so with the five airlines, and I always have to mention all of them, otherwise I get in trouble. So, if you said British Airways, but Iberia, Aer Lingus, Vueling and Level, which is a low-cost long-haul carrier out of Barcelona. So, I sit in the center, IAG, and our primary role is really to set the sustainability strategy, and then oversee its delivery across our different businesses, including those five airlines. Climate change is a pretty strategic issue, we are a major emitter, even though aviation is only 2% of aviation emissions. Our pathway to decarbonisation will be longer than others, because the challenge around implementing solutions, which we can get into. But very much we see this as an industry challenge, so it’s not down for one particular airline to solve climate change. We have to work together. So, I spent a lot of my time working with our various industry associations, be it sustainable aviation here in the UK, Airlines for Europe in Brussels, IATA, our global airline association, and our global regulator, ICAO.
Ryan Mangold
Good afternoon, everybody. Just a bit about FirstGroup, we’ve got about 6000 vehicles, which makes us one of the largest operators. We’ve got about 26% of the fleet is already going to move towards electric and is electrified. We’ve got 17 depots that are partially electrified and three depots that are fully electrified. And we made a commitment to decarbonize our regional bus business, which we sort of describe as our commercial bus business back in 2021. Just at the sort of coming to the end of Covid, and you’re making a commitment to decarbonize a fleet by 2035, you know, at that stage it was four and a half thousand vehicles by 2035 it’s quite an enormous amount of capital decision making that we were needed to make, combined with the fact that at that point the OEMs, whilst electric vehicles were starting to become more and more common, the technology wasn’t necessarily fully proven just yet. So, for simple things like, for example, the battery warranties that we were getting from the OEMs, they were around about sort of five years with a bit of an insurance overlay, we could get that up to eight years, but the actual husk of the vehicle, you know, the actual vehicle itself would last about 16 years, and so we’re having to then contemplate doing a midlife battery change. To a point where we are today, where the OEMs have cheered up a bit, because we’ve got a bit more track record of exactly how battery degradation is playing out, where 14 year warranties are possible to achieve in the marketplace, if you’re including a bit of an insurance overlay on top of that, so it’s moved quite a long distance already.
Rob Jurd
And you’ve invested order of magnitude of about 500 million over four years in decarbonisation already. Can you talk a little bit more about that infrastructure piece and how important that is?
Ryan Mangold
We’ve got about 70 depots in our portfolio, but there’s a good sort of about 20% of those that are, you know, based on what the current grid system looks like, is going to be very, very difficult for us to electrify at a sensible price point, because you just simply don’t have access to a network that’s going to provide sufficient amount of power. Our average depot is about 100 busses, broadly speaking. The battery capacity is anywhere between 400 to 500 kilowatts, and those buses come back in the evening. The majority of them being required to be charged in a very short period of time overnight. So you can just imagine the size of the energy capacity that’s got to be able to go into these depots into that very short period of time, and that’s the limiting factor for us. And so, what we’re doing at the moment, we’re trailing some clever ideas with Palmer Energy. They’ve got a battery energy storage process, which seems to be complete agnostic as to the battery type, and we are starting to install some of that capacity in depots to trial as to can we mitigate some of the size of the pipe we need in order to be able to get sufficient energy onto the depot at the time that we need it, and can we use that as a bit of an opportunity for energy arbitrage as well, in terms of time of day charging, et cetera.
Rob Jurd
UK government funding for decarbonisation is tightly constrained. There’s a lot of uncertainty. What are your views around how to navigate that and planning discipline when public funding is unpredictable?
Ryan Mangold
Yeah, I think the government funding has been incredibly important, on the basis that the total cost of ownership of these vehicles and the infrastructure is just so much greater than the diesel equivalent at the time when we kind of embarked on this journey. Now we’re sort of moving to a point where the bus pricing stayed broadly the same as it was in ’21, ’22 despite relatively high levels of inflation, but what we’re guessing is a bit more certainty on the battery life. The broad math is a bus last 16 years, battery 14 years. That means I’ve got a two-year gap. How am I going to fill that two-year gap? We’re trying to figure out sort of clever ways to be able to kind of cross that loss little bit. But there’s absolutely no doubt that the government funding has been incredibly important. It doesn’t only go into the bus price delta, you know, it’s about 350,000 pounds for a diesel bus, 450,000 pounds for an electric equivalent, but it actually goes into the infrastructure as well, which is quite a large barrier, you know, into the millions of pounds to be able to electrify some of these depots.
Rob Jurd
Jonathon, on your side, your primary decarbonisation strategy right now is really SAF. What’s the reality behind the hype on those other technologies?
Jonathon Counsell
I think the view is that yes, hydrogen and electric powered aircraft can potentially play a role, but it’s just going to take longer, particularly with hydrogen-powered aircraft. Most of the major players are now saying that’s probably in terms of a narrow body type aircraft not going to be entered into service till beyond 2050. You might see some commuter or regional aircraft before that, but they’re going to be pretty small, less than 100 seats, less than 1000 nautical miles in range. I think the big change that we’ve seen in the last five years is real convergence of view around the importance that SAF is going to play, and this is both at an industry level and a government level. So, in any scenario, SAF is going to be the primary mechanism for our industry to reduce our carbon emissions. There are different types of SAF, so we call it 1G, 2G, 3G first generation. That’s the only SAF you can buy today. It’s mature technology. It can be produced in existing refineries. It uses sort of fat soils and greases as a feedstock, and that’s probably going to serve our needs for next 10 years, but it will cap out in terms of potential supply to somewhere between 30 and 50 million tons, because of limited feedstocks. So that’s why we’re very interested in the second and third generation SAFs, the more advanced SAFs. So second generation, we talk about alcohol to jets and municipal solid waste, where you just take household waste and you convert into jet fuel, and then the third generation, this is the nirvana, this is where you take CO2 capture from the atmosphere and you mix it with green hydrogen. The importance of those two advanced pathways, they have much more availability or possibility to scale, so we will need 500 million tons of SAF by 2050. With those second and third generation SAFs, we can get there. So, they have a lot less restriction in terms of availability of feedstocks. We pretty much recognize we can’t get to net zero by just reducing our own emissions, what we call in-sector emissions. We will rely on investment, certainly in this time frame, in carbon reductions elsewhere. So, this will be through emissions trading schemes, carbon offsets. So, we have our global carbon offsetting and reduction scheme, which is agreed through our global regulator, ICAO. We’re a global industry, we need to be globally regulated, and we will be entering into the mandatory phase of course here from January 2027 and this will cover 80% of global emissions. So, the question I always get is, can you deliver net zero emission by 2050? Yes, absolutely, we can. But the question is, how? We want to do everything we can to reduce our own emissions, because we think that’s much more in our control in terms of availability of those solutions and the pricing, and that’s why SAF, I think, is going to be the primary component to enable us to get there.
Rob Jurd
It’s currently I think less than 5% of the fuel mix. Could you talk more a little bit about that cost premium? How does that price gap narrow over time, and perhaps also elaborate a little bit more around the customer adoption side of things, and how consumers feel about this?
Jonathon Counsell
We survey our customers on a regular basis, the biggest support for the different solutions we talk about is on SAF. People get SAF, you know, get the sort of aviation is very fuel intensive, and therefore coming up with a less carbon intensive fuel seems to be the obvious answer. In terms of where are we today? So, five years ago there was 50,000 tons a year of SAF. Last year 1.9 million tons. This year 2.5 million tons. Now people say it is roughly about 1% of global supply, but if you’d asked us five years ago, we’ll be doing over 2 million tons, would have bitten your hand off, you know. This is 100 times increase in supply over five years. The latest forecast is we’ll get to 20 million tons by 2030 so we’re well on the way. So, the first year of the mandates for SAF, both UK and EU, were January 2025. Started at quite low, 2%. In the EU, it stays at 2% till 2029. So all the fuel you uplift in Europe will contain 2% of SAF. In the UK, it’s 2% last year, but it linearly increases to 10% by 2030 so this year is 3.6%. The other interesting thing here is that SAF prices today, they’re following jet fuel prices, that is totally illogical, because the cost driver is completely different. SAF should follow the cost of the feedstock. We are starting to see a decoupling of SAF prices from jet fuel prices. But as with everything, it’s down to an individual company to negotiate better price, and I can say at IAG, we’re paying way below market prices for our SAF, and there’s a number of reasons for that. We’ve got scale, the key role that airlines can play in supporting the SAF market is long-term off-take agreements. Typically, on jet fuel we have 12-month agreements. For SAF, we did a deal with a third-generation power to liquid company in the US for 14 years. This is a massive change for us as a company. It took a long time to get that through our governance, mainly because of the potential risk. That’s absolutely key for the SAF producer, because it’s got bankability. They can take that contract and raise capital on the back of it. So really, that’s the primary role, and we encourage a lot of airlines to do the same, to help these SAF startups get through the development phase, and through that, you can get more competitive pricing. So, the other role, as well as doing the long-term off-take agreements, is invest in startups. So, we’ve invested in half a dozen SAF startups, just to get them through that pre-FID position, and again, that gives us access to more cost competitive SAF.
Rob Jurd
Moving over to Ryan for a minute on your side. You’re both dependent on partners and newer, earlier stage companies. You mentioned earlier, Palmer Energy, Wright Bus is another one. How critical are those industrial and tech partnerships for you to speed up decarbonisation?
Ryan Mangold
We have actually taken an equity position in Palmer as a result of what we’re doing. We’ve installed three megawatts so far, and we’re going to kind of grow that capacity as part of the sort of energy infrastructure solve we spoke about. We want to work with players that are going to be active in this space where they can learn with us, alongside them, to create better solutions for the future. And if we are going to be part of the almost sort of sand pit from a development point of view, we’d like to have some level of equity participation with the solutions that we come up with. On the partnership that we got with Wrights and there are others as well. Our diesel fleet, and there’s a large number of these vehicles, which instead of just simply running them for another sort of 8–10 years, they get to a point where the midlife, you’ve got to do a major engine overhaul, which is primarily almost replacing the entire engine with another diesel engine, and we take in the view, instead of replacing the diesel engine, let’s rather convert this to being an electric vehicle. That’s starting to get some real momentum now. We’re trialling a few buses that we’ve done the conversions of, and I think it’s going to play a relatively meaningful part in our journey at a price point that’s going to be cheaper than just going electric. Clearly, that doesn’t solve the on-site infrastructure challenge we spoke about before, and the only real partner we’ve got in that regard, really, is Palmer Energy on battery energy storage to try and reduce the amount of, and scale of energy, we need to absorb from the grid at any point in time.
Rob Jurd
As we talked about on the aviation side, customer adoption, how much do commuters think about this? How much do they care, and how does that drive your thinking?
Ryan Mangold
There’s no doubt from a customer point of view the experience is better. What we don’t have data on is whether they’re taking the bus because it is an electric bus, and they wouldn’t have taken a diesel bus before, we just don’t know that just yet. We’ve got a few depots where we’ve gone completely from diesel straight to electric 100%. We know that the level of passenger demand when we’ve done that is far greater than we would have deployed a mini fleet of diesel busses in the past, for example. And so, we’re not too sure whether that is linked to the fact that when you do something as massive as that at a local economy level, whether it’s just the publicity that comes with that, that’s getting people to say, well, I’ll try to catch the bus, and when they’ve caught the bus, they’ve realized that actually it’s a pretty decent experience.
Rob Jurd
Jonathon, you mentioned specifically earlier stage companies and SAF startups, this is obviously expected to be a very big market. There are a lot of chemicals companies that are in that broader value chain as well. We talked previously about Airbus and others creating funds and investing from the airframer side. Who are some of the other larger players that are investing in SAF and are part of that broader ecosystem?
Jonathon Counsell
Yeah, we’re not worried about 1G supply at the moment. The issue for us is the advanced SAF, that’s much less mature technology. The priority for us, is how do we help and accelerate the development of that market? Because we’ve got to get there sooner, because, as I say, the 1G market will cap out at 50 million tons, and we need 500 million tons. So, I mentioned 1212, a great company based on the West Coast of the US. They’re a 3G, so power to liquid company. We did the 14-year deal. Infinium, that’s another. So, they will start producing 3G SAF next year. We’ve got a 10 year off-take agreement. In terms of investors, there’s a whole range of investors in those companies, including the US Military, so they’ve been particularly helpful. They’ve got very ambitious carbon reduction targets, and also NASA. NASA, also a big investor. Closer to home, LanzaJet. So LanzaJet, they are probably the world’s most successful 2G SAF company, so alcohol to jet, which is probably the biggest pathway within 2G SAF. So they’ve got a plant in Georgia. It’s the first commercial scale SAF production facility in the world, and the second plant will be here in the UK, Project Speed Bird on Teesside, and that’s going to be very significant in terms of helping us meet the UK SAF mandate targets. Another interesting one, Waste Front. So, waste car tires, who knew you can turn waste car tyres into SAF? In the UK, we have 500 million waste tires a year. So, there’s a company in Sunderland. They’re building a facility that converts those waste tires into what we call tire pyrolysis oil, and that can be converted into SAF. So that’s a really interesting pathway. Globally, now we could be looking at 10 million tons a year of SAF from waste car tires. So long term off-take agreements, but with LanzaJet and Waste Front, we are investors. So, as well as offtake, we’ve actually invested in those companies. One of the other partnerships that we launched last year is through our alliance, so we’re in the One World Alliance, it’s essentially three global aviation alliances, One World, Star Alliance, and Sky Team. One World has been very active on the sustainability front, and particularly on sustainable aviation fuels. So, we’ve been talking, we’ve got 15 airlines, about 20% of global capacity. How can we work together to stimulate the global SAF market? So, can we pool our funds together, find a partner and collectively invest in these SAF companies. So, we set up a SAF fund with Breakthrough Energy Ventures, so this is one of Bill Gates’s organizations. And I have to say we looked at a lot of potential partners, these guys are in a different league when it comes to understanding the global SAF market. So, he knows more about SAF than most airline CEOs, so he’s very impressive. And they just recognize, it’s very powerful for us, because as an airline, we’re saying we think it’s SAF, but an independent organization that has no ulterior motive says the answer for aviation is SAF, and we’re going to put our money to help stimulate this market. So we launched that last year with six carriers: American Airlines, Alaska, Cathay, JAL, ourselves, and Singapore Airlines. $150 million. We’re now in the second round. It’s called the One World BEF Fund. You’ll notice that one of those airlines is not a One World Airline, Singapore Airlines. They just love the idea. They’ve always wanted to do this, and we are an open fund, we’ll attract financing from any airline, but also from the OEMs. So we’re talking to the Airbuses and Boeings. Airbus have invested in SAF companies, so they’re an investor in LanzaJet, for example. But also, airports and investors outside of the aviation industry. So, we’re looking to grow that fund and to help these startups get through that pre-FID development phase.
Rob Jurd
So maybe just a point, given you mentioned American Airlines is there and you’re part of the One World Alliance. Have you seen any change in stance from US carriers? You operate in a very global industry. Is there a difference in stance that some of the US players have taken?
Jonathon Counsell
Without a doubt, it has been challenging, because sustainability is clearly not number one in the US at the moment, but the US is very much focused on SAF production. So they see themselves, and they’ve had this policy for a number of years that they want to be a global supplier of SAF. And the current administration also supports that, you know, they describe it as helping American farmers get rich on SAF production, because they’ve got lots of feedstock, so the incentives are still there. The issue for the carriers is, it’s very difficult for them to build a business case to buy SAF, because they have no mandates, they have no demand side instruments, no mandates, and no incentives for the airlines to use it. So, while we’re seeing production come out the US, there is no demand, so a lot of that production is coming over to Europe to meet the demand through the mandates.
Rob Jurd
Yeah, and Ryan, maybe just to finish off with you, what do you see as the biggest single bottleneck on your side in terms of what you’re doing? Is it UK government, is it technology, is it customer adoption?
Ryan Mangold
I think the bottleneck is going to – it’s probably in front of us still, and that’s going to be the supply of energy and the distribution. I think that’s going to be a challenge for us in terms of the grid connectability and accessibility for us to be able to do something at a sensible price. I think that the OEM progress that’s happening, and from a manufacturing perspective, I think that’s going probably as good as we could hope. I think that sort of transition of reliability and pricing from the OEMs relative to the distribution of the actual mileage would be quite nice if that’s a much smoother curve that we can then sort of have a bit more certainty about how we’re going to be able to follow that, because that will give a greater level of confidence into the manufacturers, for example. That it’s not going to be, as you know, in terms of the scale of take up of electric vehicles and who’s going to be buying them. I don’t see real bottlenecks, I just see few areas of further improvement, but that infrastructure for the energy distribution, that’s probably going to become an issue at some point in the future.
Rob Jurd
Great, thank you, all.
Speaker 1
Thanks for listening to Powering Sustainable Ideas, brought to you by RBC Capital Markets. Please remember to subscribe for more great content and to be alerted to future episodes. This podcast was recorded on June 25, 2026. If you would like to learn more or continue the conversation, please visit us at rbccm.com/poweringsustainableideas. See you next time.
This content is based on information available at the time it was recorded, and is for informational purposes only. It is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation, and no recommendations are implied. It is outside the scope of this communication to consider whether it is suitable for you and your financial objectives.